Reviewing Jakob Nielsen's Weblog Top Ten Design Mistakes

+ Posted by Josh Hallett on 10.17.05 // 02:43 PM

Usability guru, Jakob Nielsen has posted a Alertbox update on blog design: Weblog Usability: The Top Ten Design Mistakes.

Luckily when I look over my blog and some of my client blogs I am proud to say we don't break that many of the 'rules'. I should note that Jakob is talking only about business/corporate blogs. If it's your personal blog and it's not associated with your work feel free to break all the rules.

Let's look at the top ten:

No Author Biographies
Check. Typically I like to provide a link rather than including a full bio on the page, but we have done it for some clients (Wendy has a short bio intro).

No Author Photo
I think this really depends on the blog. I sometimes feel photos are a bit to 'self-promo-ish', sort of a 'hey look at me!' thing. Plus I hate the standard headshot. I guess if that's you and how you want to be portrayed on your blog then go ahead. I would prefer something with a bit more style. You can see how we incorporated Wendy's photo in her blog template. As you can see it's not your standard headshot in a rectagular box. For WebSolvers' blog we can add some personality by showing the photo of each author next to their posts.

Nondescript Posting Titles
Sometimes guilty. As you learn who your audience is you get better at writing titles. The other major factor is search engine results. How will a title like 8:15 AM Update look on a results page? Not too exciting. There are things that you can do to edit your templates to control how your post titles appear on the blog and via search engines though.

Links Don't Say Where They Go
Sometimes guilty. I think this might be a holdover from Jakob's traditional web usability work. In a conversational tone sometimes saying the whole title of a link is not natural and sounds/reads awkward.

Classic Hits are Buried
Got this one covered. I have always had a "Most Popular Posts" section. However this will be improved and emphasized with my upcoming re-design.

The Calendar is the Only Navigation
OK on this one as well. None of the blogs I consult with use the calendar module. It's confusing and kills your search engine optimization. Want to see the worst example of this? Check out Ketchum Ideas.

Irregular Publishing Frequency
I have a good post volume, but I can't always say the same about my clients. Pick a schedule a stick with it. Even if it is only a few times per week.

Mixing Topics
Perhaps. If my blog is supposed to be about one topic then I'll agree, but most blogs reflect the interests of the individual that writes them. In the case of a business blog the posts should remain true to the core topic, but they can stray if they remain somewhat relevant.

Forgetting That You Write for Your Future Boss
Very true, but this can sometimes be a minor point. What I love about being a consultant is that I can often choose my clients. I am who I am, and if a potential client does not like that, then I probably don't want to enter into a long-term relationship with them. I enjoy working with clients that respect the fact that I am somewhat relaxed, but know what I'm talking about. I don't like to wear ties or suits and I work strange hours.

Having a Domain Name Owned by a Weblog Service
How true. The first advice to anybody is own your domain and your content (see Friends Don't Let Friends Use Bad Blogging Tools). Yes it will cost you a few dollars up-front, but it will save you plenty of hassle in the future.

What are your thoughts?

Update: Brian posts his thoughts

Update 2: Neville Hobson has his take.

Update 3: Lee agrees that sometimes providing descriptive links can hamper readability.

Visitor Comments

I think his #7 "Irregular Publishing Frequency" would be better addressed by implementing a proper and easily discovered RSS feed (something Alertbox itself lacks). That way your regular readers don't have to adjust to your publishing schedule (regular or irregular). Instead, they just have to add a blog to their aggregator and they'll learn when it has new content available.

I have a calendar on my personal blog, but it's really just for me. I can look at it and feel like a slacker because I haven't posted enough.

This guy could post top ten best ways to chew chicklets and you'd all shake yer heads in awe. I think his list is full of holes.

I myself don't agree with the need to post a picture either. Especially if you don't look great. It's best to focus on your site. If your site looks clean and you write some things that can appeal to people, then you have made a connection and visitors are able to connect with you.

Mike

I couldn't agree more.

Post Your Comment






Linking Blogs

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Reviewing Jakob Nielsen's Weblog Top Ten Design Mistakes:

» Rules of the Game from blog.websolvers
Josh has posted a very interesting run-down of Jakob Nielsen's dos and don'ts for blogs. I think that, like most cultural institutions, rules are only as good as the ways in which they're applied. I think that Jakob Nielsen, who... [Read More]

» Top Ten Weblog Usability Tips with Comments on 1-5 from Thinking Home Business
As a longtime admirer of the work of web usability expert Jakob Nielsen I was pleased to find today, via a review on Josh Hallett's hyku blog, a link to JN's list of top ten weblog design mistakes, from the point of view of usability, which is a pretty... [Read More]

» headline added later from Sticks of Fire: a Tampa blog
Jakob Nielsen’s alertbox for yesterday discusses the top ten blog design mistakes. Winter Haven blogging consultant Josh Hallett also gives us his thoughts on the list. I found the topic because Discourse.net graded his blog, and I’ll take the s... [Read More]

Blog Search
About Josh Hallett
Recent Blog Posts
More Golden Gate at Night
posted on: Aug 4, 2008 at 04:37 PM

Vote for Voce
posted on: Aug 4, 2008 at 04:31 PM

Clarity
posted on: Jul 21, 2008 at 06:03 PM

BlogHer 08 Photo Highlights
posted on: Jul 20, 2008 at 03:00 PM

Golden Gate Bridge at Night
posted on: Jul 20, 2008 at 12:03 PM

Nikon Coolpix S600 Initial Review
posted on: Jul 14, 2008 at 10:01 PM

Off to California and BlogHer Next Week
posted on: Jul 11, 2008 at 08:01 AM

BlogOrlando 2008 Registration
posted on: Jul 10, 2008 at 10:48 AM

Syndicate
Subscribe via E-mail
Where I Work

Blogs I Read
Photos
www.flickr.com
Location