As somewhat of a joke (although I do get serious at the very end) I've put together this PR Blogger Lifecycle, or the steps that new PR bloggers go thru. This isn't an original idea by any stretch of the imagination. If you haven't read Min Jung Kim's Lifecycle of Bloggers you might want to start there.
I look over some of them and say, "yep, in May of 2005, I was at step 4." Where are you on the scale? The true PR blog masters just start at Step 7.
1. What's a Blog? You don't know what a blog is, but everybody you know has one. Your initiative is part peer pressure, part curiosity. But you're cheap and even though everybody says don't go with Blogger you can't see yourself paying a few bucks a month for TypePad. After all you sent your resume out on loose-leaf paper and that got you a job in PR.
2. First Post: The first foray is awkward at first, but you soon get the hang of it. You realize that this blog thing can be a great self-promotional tool and hey you're in PR so you can do this. However your blog content is more meta than meat since you think that there is no way you can truly add to the deep discussions going on (joking here). Your style is point-to and agree with.
3. You Love Steve: Steve Rubel get's knocked a bit, but he is one of the most recognized bloggers in the PR/Marketing space. As such he's one of the first people you add to your RSS reader. The RSS reader, as you've just learned, is the must-have piece of software. In order to get recognized by Steve you comment and link away. Steve's a genius, he can do no wrong....oh look, he just linked to me, I've made it!
4. Stats Watching: How many people are reading my blog?...Look at all the traffic from Steve's link. You make your blog stats your default homepage. You worry about post-volume. Look, if I mention other bloggers they'll link to me! It goes on and on. You create blog posts that specifically appeal to the ego of other bloggers.
5. Rank Matters: Stats obsession turns to rank obsession. Dammit Technorati hasn't updated my link count in a week! You check the PubSub PR list ever day to monitor your progress, but you just can't get past that MicroPersuasion blog. Hey look, posting photos of my cute kids got me to the top of the list!!!! Your blog becomes more about building links and rank than it does providing content to your readers.
6. You Hate Steve: You say to yourself, I know more about X than this Rubel guy, how come he gets all the links/interviews/traffic/etc...So instead of commenting and praising Steve you snark and challenge. Soon you find that criticism also builds traffic.
7. Finding the Zone: An inner peace soon settles upon your blog. You say to hell with everybody else and write what you want to write. You don't follow memes and you don't post to get traffic. You post what you want to post. Readers appreciate this, in many cases it's why they started to read you in the first place. You were a fresh voice, but the previous steps marginalized this.
8. You Accept Steve (and everybody else): Sometime you agree with Mr. Rubel, other times you disagree, but that's what's great about the blogosphere, you can have a debate and sometimes we all learn something in the process.
9. Relationships: You continue to build relationships with other bloggers and they become some of your best friends and colleagues. If you have a question or a client issue they can help solve it. When you attend conferences and finally meet them in person it's like you've known each other for years, because you have.
10. Starting Over (Goodbye Blogger/TypePad): In the ultimate act of penance for your earlier Rank-Chasing misdeeds you start all over again. Many times it's because you've outgrown Blogger or TypePad, or you've changed jobs, or you just want a fresh start.
With a new blog you start from scratch. No links, no rank, but it doesn't matter because all your friends help you move. In the end you'd much rather have those relationships with friends than links or visitors or PageRank.












Visitor Comments
Hah! I think there's an element of truth in this.
I'm a bit mixed between. I'd say I'm at 4 and 5, but also at 7.
I do all of number 7 but I still check my stats and traffic now and again. I'm also a little on number 9 too.
P.S. I've never hated Steve. Oops! Does that mean I love him? I can't be a number 3 too! :-)
Posted by: Stephen Davies | March 27, 2006 5:44 PM
What if you've never even been on PubSub, don't read Rubel, and hover between 7 and 9?
Answer: You join Ike in the "has 12 devoted readers" club.
Posted by: Ike | March 27, 2006 6:05 PM
What a neat way to look at blogging. I am a relatively new blogger, and it was a good way for me to get an overview of the blogging lifecycle. It also helped me to get an idea of some things i might need to learn more about.
I am blogging for a class and we have discussed several of the things you mentioned. We recently discussed tracking and I am already kind of addicted to watching the traffic. I guess you could say i'm at step four even though I have no opinions one way or the other toward Steve Rubel.
I liked your comment about relationships. Blogging is a great way to make lasting connections with other business professionals and to continuously network. I know several people who have even landed jobs through blogging.
Posted by: katherine | March 27, 2006 6:10 PM
Hey.. two links in one post! thanks for helping my linkranks!! you rock!
Posted by: david parmet | March 27, 2006 7:07 PM
You're right my friend, it's all in the relationships!
Posted by: Toby | March 28, 2006 12:30 AM
Whoo hoo! I've progressed from Step 4 to 5. Now if only Technorati and Pub Sub would fix my link rank. (I've already contacted them and had a response, but no love yet.)
So, I'm going to start hating Steve soon? Didn't realize that. I'm not Strumpette. But mine did grow overnight in 7th grade. :)
Posted by: Jen | March 28, 2006 12:44 AM
Ha, ha, ha...
Very funny and very truthful!
Posted by: Octavio Isaac Rojas Orduña | March 28, 2006 5:53 AM
Okay, okay, that was wrong of me. Both Technorati and Pub Sub have been helpful with my link rank issues. (Steven from Pub Sub has been especially helpful.) I can't help it--it's a slight obsession now. I'm totally in the middle of Step 5; hopefully I'll move on to hating Steve soon.
Posted by: Jen | March 28, 2006 10:29 AM
Great post, Josh and great to see you last week!
Marianne
Posted by: Marianne Richmond | March 28, 2006 11:42 AM
Step 5:
"Your blog becomes more about building links and rank than it does providing content to your readers."
Honest to God, Josh, do you really believe this is true of Media Orchard?
Posted by: scott | March 28, 2006 3:52 PM
Scott:
Not completely....I think whether we admit to it or not, most of us have been somewhere on that list at one point. It can even change from post to post.
Posted by: Josh Hallett | March 28, 2006 5:40 PM
Josh - don’t forget No. 11:
Nude masthead for blog.
Posted by: makethelogobigger | March 28, 2006 6:52 PM
Your answer reveals some serious PR skillz, Josh...kudos.
Posted by: scott | March 28, 2006 10:27 PM
I'd no idea I was a a sterotype blogger until i read this. I'm not sure I have gone through all the stages in exactly the right order but it's pretty close ;-)
Posted by: David Rossiter | March 29, 2006 10:51 AM
Josh,
You are too clever by far!
Posted by: Debbie Weil | March 31, 2006 4:21 PM
Too true to be funny! Yuk Yuk!
Posted by: Sherrilynne | April 5, 2006 3:45 AM
You really cracked me up, Josh. My cycle was more like 7-8-9-5.
Right from the start, I knew I was not going to blog about my line of work (PR and marketing). Instead I chose a topic that's close to my heart - books, mostly romance. However, recently, I found myself itching to have my say about other topics.
Would you believe I've been contemplating step 10 lately? Yes, migrating, own domain and all. That's some creepy crystal ball gazing you've got there!!
For someone who obsessively watches site links and ranks at work, I try not to get too caught up promoting my own. So, thanks for that wake-up call in step 10.
Posted by: ag | April 5, 2006 7:43 AM
Hi Josh
Great points. Guess I'm somewhere near the fifth point. Still to hate Steve. Let's see. Guess that's why I'm putting my blog's name instead of my name- linking and SEO stuff :-)
Well, what the hell, let's see if this works too Public Relations India
Posted by: Public Relations India | May 28, 2006 1:04 PM