Why Blog Monitoring is Useless Without Community Context (or Another Analogy)

+ Posted by Josh Hallett on 10.09.07 // 09:10 AM

In my previous post I put forth an analogy to illustrate a point. I do that quite a bit in training sessions. I'm constantly comparing online/social media situations to things we see in everyday life. Analogies help those just learning about social media find a relationship to what they're used to. (Big Social Media Consultant Secret: Many of rules you use in personal interaction offline, apply online :-) pass that along.)

Conversational monitoring, blog monitoring, persistent keyword searches...whatever you call them are a standard item in any social media toolkit, but what do you do with the results? As in what is actionable? What is important and needs immediate response, and what can wait? None of the paid services offer this function (that I've seen). You need to be involved with the community to know the impact.

Here's another analogy:

Imagine you're at a coffee shop and you overhear somebody talking about a subject/client in a positive/negative way. What are your options?

A. If it's your local coffee shop and you've lived in that community for a number of years chances are you might know the person or the subject very well. You would know that person's standing in the community. Are they like E.F. Hutton? When they talk do others listen? Or are they the village idiot? In this case you could start up a conversation in a natural manner, or introduce yourself. Chances are the other person knows you, or at least has 'seen you around'.

Once you start that conversation the discussion is wide open. Maybe you state your case, perhaps you change their mind, or at least get them to see your side of the issue. The point is you know all the social intricacies of the situation. You know that talking to one person will take care of the issue, and that person will talk to you.

or...

B. You're on a trip far from home and the 'local' coffee shop is somewhere you've never been before. You're the 'stranger' sitting by themselves in the corner, the locals are asking, "Who's that?" How did you get here? Some search dropped you here.

When that person across the room talks, you have no idea who they are and what their standing in the community is. You have no idea what the impact of their statements are. How do you approach them and introduce yourself? We've been in situations like this before. Introductions like that can be awkward to say the least.

Talking to that person might actually make the situation worse. You just don't know.

Spend a week in the coffee shop though, and your situation changes.

If you've been doing your homework and have built a presence in a particular community, we can add an Option C:

C. It's your local coffee shop and you've lived in that community for a number of years. Somebody has a problem/comment. Rather than saying something to a group of folks, they come directly to you first. Perhaps it's a genuine issue, or it's a simple misperception. However, a few quick, private words between friends takes care of everything.

Visitor Comments

Well said, Josh. I'd much rather build strong relationships, strong enough that people can call me out one on one and iron things out. Of course, that means as a community manager I must listen and be respectful.

Good Post. Sometimes we feel anonymous online and forget our manners. The social graces still apply.

Exactly!

It's always so... well, funny isn't the word... sadly predictable? when a new commenter shows up at a blog that has an established community, and posts a comment full of bluster and vitriol. And then acts all shocked and surprised when people are pissed off.

Uh, it's because we *don't know who the hell you are*, and you obviously didn't take the time to get to know who *we* are! It's really not that difficult a concept.

Hi Josh - Good stuff. Seems you've not only recovered but are rejuvenated after BlogOrlando! ;)

I've used that very analogy in my media/reputation management training for years now - and the application in Social Media monitoring is a natural fit. And props to you, it is well-explained.

I don't know, Amber. That seems like it could lead to a closed community that is self reenforcing. In other words, what you described seems like more like an echo chamber than a community.

But then again, I'm the kind of person that likes to be challenged, as well as be challenging. Maybe that's just me.

Great analogy, Josh! It really helped me see your point clearly.

I just found one that does give you action items - it's from the UK (now in beta) and it's called Brandseye.

Josh,

We here at Visible Technologies could not agree with more, which is why we've developed the industry's first and only Response Manager that allows companies to participate in those online conversations. Actionable marketing is where everyone is headed and we're thrilled to be part of it.

Post Your Comment






Blog Search
About Josh Hallett
Recent Blog Posts
Welcome Doug
posted on: Jan 29, 2010 at 08:48 AM

Social Media is the 'Last Mile' - Part 3 - Scaling
posted on: Jan 21, 2010 at 10:51 AM

Transparency is BS - Long Live Transparency
posted on: Jan 20, 2010 at 04:45 PM

Lakeland Local and Sticks of Fire in MediaShift
posted on: Jan 15, 2010 at 08:41 AM

Social Media is the 'Last Mile' - Part 2 - The Internal War
posted on: Jan 14, 2010 at 09:52 AM

Social Media is the 'Last Mile' - Part 1
posted on: Jan 13, 2010 at 05:15 PM

Sorry, We Work in Different Industries
posted on: Jan 13, 2010 at 01:17 PM

Correction to Ledger Article
posted on: Jan 8, 2010 at 07:13 AM

Syndicate
Subscribe via E-mail
Where I Work

Blogs I Read
Photos
www.flickr.com
Location